YDS: The Clare Spark Blog

February 27, 2012

Chardon High School, “negativity” and depth psychology

I woke up to the news of the shooting of several students at Chardon High School, Ohio. As I write this, pundits are already attempting to add to the paucity of concrete detail regarding this student shooter with reassurances and/or warnings to parents. All we know as I write this at 12:20 PST, is that the shooter is a male, that he had made his preoccupation with death and vengeance known on Facebook last December, and that he shot his ex-girl friend’s new boy friend, Daniel Parmertor, now killed. Four other students are wounded. There may be more deaths. [Added 2-28: two more students have died, and the shooter was a student at a special school for "at risk" students; also described as "outcast."]

Ever since I started reading about the history of American culture, I have heard endless repetitions on the theme that we are a violent people, owing to our history. And yet, polls seem to show that “negativity” in political ads is often rejected by a populace that is notoriously bloodthirsty and amoral. (Ask Cormac McCarthy about this.)

In prior blogs I have ruminated about the strong lobby against psychiatry and other mental health services, although we know a great deal more about child development than, say, our forebears at the beginning of the modern period in about the 16th century and 17th centuries, when witch burnings and other forms of torture were common in popular and high culture alike.

I have also argued that the particular form of co-optation of 1960s protest movements produced a willed refusal to look at what was common in human nature. Multiculturalism asserted that only members of a race or gender were able to opine about groups in which they did not belong, owing to the group “character” of the oppressed group du jour. Multiculturalists, along with their Stalinoid enemies, also made great generalizations about our national character. Amerikka was held to be essentially imperialistic, money-mad, racist, patriarchal, ecocidal, genocidal, and so on. Graduate students in  history were more likely to get a job if they adhered to this catechism, especially if they could prove their competence in “whiteness studies.”

It happened that the psycho-historian Peter Loewenberg (illustrated) was a professor in my department at UCLA, but his focus on power relations in numerous types of  “families” was considered to be a specialty beyond the ken of ordinary graduate students like myself, who were told by the numerous social historians that it was better to identify with the grass roots or mobs and their laudable resistance to upper-class atrocities, than to follow the path cleared by Freud, and before him the acute insights into individual and group psychology offered by every great writer in the history of the West, starting with Greek tragedy, and going on through Shakespeare, Milton, Goethe, Schiller, and many others. (And I have not mentioned the revelations of the great visual artists, and before them, archaic religions, all of which interested Freud and his better followers.)

It is not likely that even our best private schools, aimed at training leaders, delve into the affective lives of their students, other than to preach against “hate” and to promote “tolerance” of those who are “different.” What would Freud have said? What did our Founding Fathers think? Where did the notion of childhood innocence come from? I will leave that last question unanswered for now. (Don’t blame the Jews. The better educated among us have no illusions about benevolent human nature, agreeable to shaping by social engineers educated by Rousseau.)

Clearly, there is a dark side to human nature, and it is common to every one of us. But the anti-psychiatry and anti-capitalist culture in which we swim does not consider our material bodies appropriate objects of study. Yet we are seething with rage, jealousy, and longings for revenge—emotions that are part of our human equipment from birth. In the medieval past, these common qualities were attributes of the Devil, and in this life, we were in his snares and subject to his constant lying. Madness was attributed to demonic possession, and many the death-dealing remedies that were offered to purge us of his maleficent urges.

Many pious Americans still believe in the Devil, and believe that “secularists” (include in that category psychologists, feminists and Jews) are in his serpentine grasp. But because teaching children how to manage their “negative” emotions is considered to be a violation of parental rights, schools back away from challenging the medievalists among us. Meanwhile, kids are flooded with terrifying images of monsters, vampires, zombies, and other projections of their forbidden anger—anger at being bullied, lied to, overestimated, underestimated, pushed, neglected, abandoned to the mass media (including comic books)– but make your own list of treacherous adult conduct.

Similarly, “narcissism” is now considered to be a personality disorder and also the chief feature of laissez-faire (a.k.a. free market) capitalism, according to many progressive intellectuals. Yet little girls are taught from early childhood to emulate the glitterati, turning themselves into decorative objects for the sexual delectation of strangers, men, and even family members.

It is now “cool” to identify with the demonic and with criminals. It is one way to defy authoritarian parents and authoritarian ideas, one desperate way to feel a modicum of power.  We are committing mass suicide in our resistance to taking a detailed family history, including how every institution we inhabit deals with the dark side of human nature.

About these ads

5 Comments »

  1. “But because teaching children how to manage their “negative” emotions is considered to be a violation of parental rights, schools back away from challenging the medievalists among us”
    Clare, are you sure that you are talking about American children? Isn’t everyone taught carnegianism (smile, don’t argue) and corporatism (negativity/positivity, whining, anger management, etc) from prenatal care? Aren’t fetuses in psychological care from conception? Isn’t everyone on psychological couch long before the conception? What country are you talking about?
    I actually attended different pre-university schools in two different countries and never heard about child psychology. I also never heard about shooting in schools or anywhere else.

    Comment by anna — February 27, 2012 @ 11:16 pm | Reply

    • I’m talking about the US, and though there is plenty of psychobabble, it is usually confined to police profilers. There is plenty of superstition indoctrinated into our children.

      Comment by clarespark — February 27, 2012 @ 11:20 pm | Reply

  2. “I have also argued that the particular form of co-optation of 1960s protest movements produced a willed refusal to look at what was common in human nature. Multiculturalism asserted that only members of a race or gender were able to opine about groups in which they did not belong, owing to the group “character” of the oppressed group du jour. Multiculturalists, along with their Stalinoid enemies, also made great generalizations about our national character. Amerikka was held to be essentially imperialistic, money-mad, racist, patriarchal, ecocidal, genocidal, and so on. Graduate students in history were more likely to get a job if they adhered to this catechism, especially if they could prove their competence in “whiteness studies.”” [*Note You just saved 10,000 hours of research/reading/viewing time...Courtesy of the highly-regarded Dr. Spark. Thank you, Clare.]

    Spark captures the past better than any digital attempt!

    Respectfully always,

    Dr. Gary Katz
    The Wright Institute – Berkeley, California, USA; Hebrew University – Jerusalem, Israel

    Comment by gk68 — February 27, 2012 @ 10:08 pm | Reply

  3. Dr. Spark directs us dynamically, as always, to the central core of the “Left”‘s mass “negative hallucinations” [*NOT seeing what IS there, in front us, nor perceiving a reliable representation of that reality, e.g. the foul& ferociously orgiastic multiple murders of American kids (soldiers) in Afghanistan in the past 2 days by IslamoNazis, whose ferocity and glee with Darkness/Death Worship rites and mass institutionalized atrocities against girls/women….hundreds of millions in the Islamic world, are not viewable by the dissociative pathology of utopian denial & identification with the aggressor [such soothing pacifiers).
    Then, as body parts of human beings (some of them whom they might have even met or known) are being meticulously bagged, so as to facilitate a timely, dignified burial with {as much as possible, in today's grisly, barbarian calculus} the ENTIRE body interred do not EXIST in the mind of the mesmerized masses of leftists and their (student) descendants, as they gleefully and corruptly dismantle a culture, a culture which at least had the brilliance to identify the most crucial developmental tasks of all..."impulse control" and its distortion, so that tearing an American kid apart dragging and eating and holding up as "id" Trophies the very parts of that once-human being.
    It's Time for "legitimate authority" to STOP this out-of-control Islamist/leftist-enabled global mass killing (See R.N. Sanford et al; "The Authoritarian Personality"; 1950; UC Berkeley; Stanford Univ., after his firing for refusal to sign McCarthy's "Loyalty Oath") and more.......(to be continued...>]

    Comment by gk68 — February 27, 2012 @ 10:01 pm | Reply

    • Dr. Gary Katz is in fine form. I agree with every sentence and with his anger and frustration as well.

      Comment by clarespark — February 27, 2012 @ 10:10 pm | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Rubric Theme. Blog at WordPress.com.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,275 other followers

%d bloggers like this: