YDS: The Clare Spark Blog

November 21, 2015

SCANDAL’s “inclusive” feminism

Shonda

Shonda Rhimes with cast members

SCANDAL, the ABC show created by Shonda Rhimes (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shonda_Rhimes), is hugely popular, and boasts a demographic of mostly women, ages 18-49. This blog is about two trends embodied in this show that can be traced back to the late 1960s: liberal-sponsored Black Power and the related move of liberal feminist “role-reversal”.

(For key scenes from the winter finale, 2015, see http://abc.go.com/shows/scandal/news/recap/season-5-episode-9-recap-winter-finale-baby-its-cold-outside-olitz-111915.

I had been particularly uncomfortable with the last two episodes, as the heroine Olivia Pope fulfilled one liberal feminist fantasy: female supremacy, as opposed to what leftists and liberal feminists alike see as the subjugation of women that is akin to slavery.  In the penultimate episode (#8), the heroine (played by Kerry Washington) was moved into the White House by her lover “Fitz” (Tony Goldwyn playing POTUS).  Olivia, usually the super-fixer, proceeded to take charge of all executive decisions, thus echoing her super-powerful father’s commanding role as the head of a secret organization that is really in charge of the nation. This is black power on steroids.

JoeMortonDirects

Joe Morton as Director

The season finale continues in this strain, but adds to the black supremacy-liberal feminist theme: there is a filibuster in defense of Planned Parenthood, conducted by the ambitious ex-First Lady “Mellie” now a [moderate] Republican Senator for Virginia (aided and abetted by Olivia and the female vice-president, underlining the theme of female solidarity across race lines, much to the disgust of a male Senator presumably from the Deep South); moreover Olivia has an abortion without telling Fitz (we presume he is the father); out of family solidarity she spares her father (who had been marked for execution) but then “Rowan” (played by Joe Morton) goes on a tirade against families as inevitable agents of destruction in a voice-over played over the abortion scene.

OliviaPopeabortionre

Olivia Pope abortion shot

Is there not a typical liberal double bind here? Olivia enjoys wielding power over men, but complains that being First Lady (with its uber-housewifely duties) is a form of slavery (she uses the word “property” in her break-up scene with Fitz). She ends up with her bottle of fine red wine, all alone, back in her apartment surrounded by Christmas decorations: a single woman ready to vote for Hillary. The background music is Schubert’s Ave Maria.

For me, feminism has always been about equality, not supremacy. For many women (not just inhabitants of Red States) the role of wife and mother is a great and satisfying job, while often a conflicted collaboration. It is strange that Shonda Rhimes, a Dartmouth graduate, never learned that life lesson.

 

Advertisements

2 Comments »

  1. The purpose of any legitimate “civil rights” movement, including feminism, is to achieve equality of opportunity, not outcome. The exercise of female superiority over men may be perceived as an advance or an equalizing of power in relationships, but it has betrayed the fundamental principle of recognizing the individual as having value. Basing one’s identity on groups and celebrating one’s victimhood as part of that group, leads to the mistaken conclusion that equality is achieved by oppressing the oppressor “equal” to the victimhood one feels.

    This is irrational.

    You can’t tear down the old structural racism, by erecting new structural racism, and you can’t liberate women by oppressing men.

    I haven’t seen the episode of the show that you are reviewing, but I have heard about it. Conservatives are upset about the abortion scene, in part, because “Silent Night” is being played in the background. (You say it is “Ave Maria.”) Olivia then goes back home to enjoy Christmas and a bottle of wine.

    Obviously, this episode was intended to provoke. Part of the attack here is on Christian values, but it is a progressive political and cultural middle finger to “normal” or “conservative” beliefs about the consequences of abortion. It is indeed a fantasy to think that abortion is so causally dismissed with drinks around the Christmas tree. By way of contrast, my wife lost her first baby on Christmas Day, and it was a devastating experience that fourteen years has not erased. She carries guilt for his death.

    Political corruption, abortion, and denunciation of the family. Is this the best that 50 years of black liberation and feminism can come up with for entertainment or even thoughtful commentary?

    Comment by Scott Lloyd — November 28, 2015 @ 4:16 am | Reply

    • I was critical of the episode. And I watched it twice. I am confident that the abortion scene was matched by Rowan’s denunciation of families.

      Comment by clarelspark — November 28, 2015 @ 6:46 am | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: