The Clare Spark Blog

May 4, 2017

Did Hillary fail or was it the labor policies of the Democratic Party?

Filed under: Uncategorized — clarelspark @ 7:36 pm
Tags: , , , , ,

occupy-dc-cornel-west-wideIf Donald J. Trump’s base is the white working class, then it raises the question, how did it come to pass that the candidate of the Democratic Party, once known as the Party of the working man, fumbled?

The well-funded Mrs. Clinton claims that misogyny in tandem with James Comey’s interventions determined her fate in 2016, and perhaps those were to an unknowable extent operative, but we must ask if labor unions solved the problems of industrial society as old time pols insist? (See and )

Recall that the period following the Civil War was also a period of extensive immigration to fill the burgeoning labor demand, and that Democrats were a Party that had persisted in a period characterized by westward expansion and urbanization (while Republicans had been the voice of Big Business and agrarian nativism.) Workers were raising hell, as students of the late 19th century (e.g., Robert Wiebe’s The Search for Order) will acknowledge, and (leftist) historians will mark the Progressive movement as responding to strikes and immigration (even as some condemn these WASPs for racism. e.g.,

Democrats did not solve the problem of nativism (exacerbated by necessary immigration to develop the continent—also the predictable opposition of displaced Indians and Mexicans); instead they catered to the ethnic preferences of the new Americans, leaving us with the New Deal “innovation” of multiculturalism as a mode by which elites could micromanage group conflict (, pretty much as labor unions would fare, strengthened in the New Deal, ostensibly to ameliorate worker suffering in future depressions and to advance “cooperation” over (Darwinist) “competition.” And so FDR and his supporters maintained their class position, though the consequences for “labor” were not what “cooperation” had promised.

But don’t expect the very “Green” Democratic Party to raise the question of the effectiveness of labor unions in solving the deeper problems of industrial society—namely the mind-numbing nature of de-skilled “labor” and worker health and safety. Without a qualm bleeding hearts condemn their (inferior) fellow human beings to a life blessed at best by gross material satisfactions, for the redder Democratic Party hearts crave equality of condition, not equality of opportunity to scale the heights of human possibility.

1 Comment »

  1. It is a quest for Power. I’ve not made much of a study of the late 1800’s but have crossed upon Labor/Management issues. Such as the film Heaven’s Gate is supposedly showing the viewers the issues around the Johnson County War mingled with turn of the Century Socialist tendencies. It is a period I wish to study up more on, the Gilded Age, as at this point, what little I do know of Teddy Roosevelt, a Republican, yet also a Trust Buster and against hyphenated Americans, wanting immigrants to join in, not hold themselves separate. He was considered a Progressive yet I do not think he was for pulling Indian Youth away from their Families and sending them to Carlyle, that was a progressive notion but I do not think the same kind as Teddy. There in lies some needed Clarification, who exactly was what? In your headline posted question on Hillary, it’s all just her quest to Run Something I think is the quote I read. Their policies enriched them and those who enriched them, they set up China was the Worlds Manufacturer of goods while placating their Union Supporters, who incidentally were part and parcel in aiding in pushing Companies off shore. I’ve read statistics about private sector Union participation and it was very low, Public Sector is through the roof and they run the States they are in. Hillary just ran out of Useful Idiots.

    Comment by hrwolfe — August 24, 2020 @ 11:59 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: